Response to Daily Mail article on Self Harm

Dr Alys Cole-King writes:

“I have just read the article on self harm in today’s Daily Mail (6/9/12, p.47). I am very disappointed. I contributed to the piece in good faith     and spent a considerable amount of time preparing a summary of the current research evidence and giving the journalist an accurate picture    of the problem.

The journalist has quoted me correctly but I am extremely concerned in the level of repetitive detail in the article regarding the methods used in self harm. The opening paragraph is particularly lurid and   sensationalist. I asked the journalist specifically not to include this     kind of detail, pointing out the evidence that publicising methods of      self harm can lead to increased incidence of self harming behaviour.

I am equally dismayed by the lack of any positive message in the article regarding what people can do to help themselves, or to support people they are worried about.  I am deeply concerned that the article may cause worry and distress to vulnerable young people and their family and friends. A parent or relative of a young person who self harms, on  reading this article is likely to feel more hopeless rather less, since      there is no positive message given or information about the various sources of help and support available. As a parent it would upset and concern me to read the article if I did not know all the positive aspects     as I do, particularly that people can be helped and that a lot of self-harming behaviour in adolescents resolves on its own – a fact which itself could provide a great deal of hope and reassurance to many.

It is easy for young people to feel overwhelmed when upsetting things happen.  They have not yet developed or refined their coping skills and they may feel that some problems are outside of their control or with no simple answer. Enhancing coping and resilience by helping them think about developing   personal control can make the difference. In    addition, ‘Talking not Harming’ is an important transition in the road    to recovery – the more appropriate supportive opportunities available for an individual who self-harms, the greater the likelihood distress can be minimised.

Key messages:

  • Every contact with individuals who self-harm is a   chance to address the emotional distress that they are feeling.
  • Early intervention can prevent escalation of   self-harming behaviours and can establish other coping strategies that are not harmful.
  • It is never too late to take action to help a situation that seems hopeless.

 Concerned adults should respond in a caring and non judgemental way. This will create a good foundation for your discussions

This in turn will enhance the willingness of the young person to accept further help and thus may lead to reduction of self-harming behaviours. Suggestions for talking to a someone who you think has self-harmed or  is thinking about self –harm involve:

  • Calm, caring manner
  • Active listening
  • Open body language
  • Safe environment where you will not be interrupted
  • Non-judgemental/no blame approach
  • Appropriate eye contact
  • Reflection – show them that you are listening to what they are telling you

It is never too late to take action to help a situation that seems hopeless- Help is available if you just know what to do and where to go.

Many people do not know how to approach someone who they think might be engaging in self -harm and people who are distressed or overwhelmed and considering self harm do not know where to go for help. We have produced a series of leaflets on behalf of the Royal    College of Psychiatrists giving information on how to cope.

The U Can Cope resource is particularly aimed towards young people to build their ability to cope with life’s difficulties and build their     resilience. This is freely available via the internet and we are also    raising money via the U Can Cope charity to distribute pocket sized leaflets as widely as possible.

These are available for free through the Royal College of Psychiatrists  and the Connecting with People website

 Royal College of Psychiatrists: http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/mentalhealthinfo/youngpeople/ ucancope.aspx

And the Connecting with People website http://www.connectingwithpeople.org/

Finally, I would like everyone to know that:

  • Thousands of people are overwhelmed every day … but find ways  to get through these intense feelings -  like them, you can get through it
  • You just have to cope with one day at a time
  •  Your distress can be a sign that you need to change something in your life”

2 thoughts on “Response to Daily Mail article on Self Harm

  1. Hi Alys
    I totally agree with your response family and friends have also feedback agreeing with your views on this. Was there need for so much detail?

  2. Well said Alys – It is lamentable that despite the media guidelines on the reportage of suicide and self-harm they still persist in dehumanising emotional distress and instead concentrate on pornographically lurid shock tactics. Is this really helpful to their readers? This approach perpetuates the propoganda of silence which locks people further into their pain. It’s not very helpful.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s